Oh, it definitely throws strong typing right out of the window.
The reason I suggested it is because it would seem that almost all of the time where you go to do an increment on a nil value, you're working with an uninitialized element (not necessarily in a hash map) and treating that as 0 (as you're doing an increment) would in a certain sense be reasonable behaviour.
But I guess you're right, in the case where nil does represent an error, it'll be two steps backwards when you go to debug the thing.
